conv.

All stories
ClimateActive · 14h

Monbiot: Climate tipping point is within reach, don't surrender to despair

Guardian columnist argues social systems can flip rapidly, citing fossil fuels' declining economics and renewable energy's ascent as signs of inevitable change.

Monbiot: Climate tipping point is within reach, don't surrender to despair
theguardian.com

Conversation activity · last 15 hours peak 4/30m

Peak 4 items in one 30m at Aug 11, 6 AM; 10 items over 15 hours Aug 11, 6:08 AM — no itemsAug 11, 6:38 AM — 4 items · Mastodon 2, Press 2Aug 11, 7:08 AM — no itemsAug 11, 7:38 AM — no itemsAug 11, 8:08 AM — 2 items · Google News 1, Hacker News 1Aug 11, 8:38 AM — no itemsAug 11, 9:08 AM — no itemsAug 11, 9:38 AM — no itemsAug 11, 10:08 AM — no itemsAug 11, 10:38 AM — 1 item · Mastodon 1Aug 11, 11:08 AM — no itemsAug 11, 11:38 AM — no itemsAug 11, 12:08 PM — no itemsAug 11, 12:38 PM — 1 item · Mastodon 1Aug 11, 1:08 PM — no itemsAug 11, 1:38 PM — no itemsAug 11, 2:08 PM — no itemsAug 11, 2:38 PM — no itemsAug 11, 3:08 PM — 1 item · Bluesky 1Aug 11, 3:38 PM — no itemsAug 11, 4:08 PM — no itemsAug 11, 4:38 PM — no itemsAug 11, 5:08 PM — no itemsAug 11, 5:38 PM — 1 item · Mastodon 1Aug 11, 6:08 PM — no itemsAug 11, 6:38 PM — no itemsAug 11, 7:08 PM — no itemsAug 11, 7:38 PM — no itemsAug 11, 8:08 PM — no itemsAug 11, 8:38 PM — no items 4 items · 6:38 AM
8 AM12 PM4 PMnow · 9:08 PM

Summary, timeline and people extracted by Claude from 10 items across 5 sources · 2h ago. Quotes are verbatim.

George Monbiot published an essay in The Guardian arguing that despair about climate breakdown is both self-fulfilling and irrational, pointing to historical tipping points (Ireland's shift from theocracy, communism's collapse) as evidence that seemingly permanent systems can transform suddenly. He contends that fossil fuels are already losing economic ground to renewables, suggesting a tipping point on climate action may be approaching.

  • Monbiot argues that social systems—like societies, governments, and economic orders—have tipping points where rapid, unexpected transformation becomes possible.
  • He cites Ireland's shift from Catholic theocracy to legal marriage equality and abortion rights as a model of seemingly impossible change happening in decades.
  • Fossil fuels are no longer the unassailable economic force they once were; renewables now generate more employment and are cheaper, signaling a potential tipping point.
  • Despair is both self-fulfilling and strategically useful to those defending the status quo; rational hope and sustained pressure can accelerate inevitable change.

How it unfolded

  1. Reaction Covering Climate Now echoes core thesis

    The climate journalism initiative Covering Climate Now amplifies Monbiot's framing about social tipping points and journalism's role in driving change.

  2. Monbiot shares his own essay on Bluesky, emphasizing that despair is irrational and that change can happen at 'astonishing speed,' with the 'flip' potentially already underway.

    “Despair is not just wrong. It's irrational. Things can change, at astonishing speed. In fact, the flip might be happening already.”

    George Monbiot · Mastodon ↗
  3. The essay is shared on Hacker News by user jahnu, gaining early traction among the tech-literate audience.

  4. George Monbiot's article appears in The Guardian's membership section, arguing that social systems have tipping points where the 'impossible' becomes 'inevitable,' and that climate breakdown may be approaching such a shift.

What people are saying verbatim

“There are social tipping points when the seemingly impossible suddenly becomes inevitable. Good journalism plays an essential role in helping drive these shifts and shows us how real change can happen.”

George Monbiot · The Guardian ↗

“Despair is self-fulfilling; despair is disempowering; despair is what the bastards want you to feel. But above all, despair is irrational.”

George Monbiot · The Guardian ↗

“I think we could be approaching a tipping point on climate breakdown. For years we've been told, 'You're asking for the moon. Fossil fuels are here to stay.' But now, as the Guardian's reporting has shown, suddenly fossil fuels are far more expensive than renewables.”

George Monbiot · The Guardian ↗

“Despair is not just wrong. It's irrational. Things can change, at astonishing speed. In fact, the flip might be happening already.”

George Monbiot · Bluesky ↗ · Aug 11, 11:08 AM

“Never give up, never give in! Positive change does happen!!”

jhlyon@mastodon.social, Mastodon user · Mastodon ↗ · Aug 11, 1:03 PM

Voices from the web unedited

  • Despair is not just wrong. It's irrational. Things can change, at astonishing speed. In fact, the flip might be happening already. My article for the Guardian's climate support campaign. www.theguardian.com/membership/2... Don’t despair about what’s hap...

    georgemonbiot.bsky.social@bsky.brid.gyMastodon · mstdn.social10h ago30▲view on Mastodon ↗
  • “There are social tipping points when the seemingly impossible suddenly becomes inevitable. Good journalism plays an essential role in helping drive these shifts and shows us how real change can happen.” By @georgemonbiot.bsky.social for @theguardian.com

    coveringclimatenow.orgBluesky5h ago7▲view on Bluesky ↗
  • 🔴Does the news make you feel desperate? 🔴Climate collapse makes you feel like you could throw up for days? 🔴Trump’ acrobatics get on your ballsack? 💙 Never give up, never give in! 💛 Positive change does happen!! https://www. theguardian.com/membership/202…

    jhlyon@mastodon.socialMastodon · journa.host8h ago3▲view on Mastodon ↗